If you spent any time in commerce circles in 2025, you couldn’t move for talk of AI agents. Every conference, every newsletter, every vendor pitch promised the same thing: autonomous AI would soon handle the entire customer journey, end-to-end.
It was compelling, but it was also premature.
Even the industry’s biggest players are recalibrating, with OpenAI recently pivoting its Agentic Commerce Protocol (ACP) and abandoning its ‘instant checkout’.
You’ve probably noticed this yourself. The gap between what AI agents can theoretically do and what your payment stack, your bank, and your customers are actually ready for is wider than the headlines suggest.
Strip away the noise, and the reality of agentic commerce splits into two distinct paths. They operate on very different timelines, and they carry very different levels of risk for your P&L today. Let’s take a look at what those are.
If you spent any time in commerce circles in 2025, you couldn’t move for talk of AI agents. Every conference, every newsletter, every vendor pitch promised the same thing: autonomous AI would soon handle the entire customer journey, end-to-end.
It was compelling, but it was also premature.
Even the industry’s biggest players are recalibrating, with OpenAI recently pivoting its Agentic Commerce Protocol (ACP) and abandoning its ‘instant checkout’.
You’ve probably noticed this yourself. The gap between what AI agents can theoretically do and what your payment stack, your bank, and your customers are actually ready for is wider than the headlines suggest.
Strip away the noise, and the reality of agentic commerce splits into two distinct paths. They operate on very different timelines, and they carry very different levels of risk for your P&L today. Let’s take a look at what those are.
If you spent any time in commerce circles in 2025, you couldn’t move for talk of AI agents. Every conference, every newsletter, every vendor pitch promised the same thing: autonomous AI would soon handle the entire customer journey, end-to-end.
It was compelling, but it was also premature.
Even the industry’s biggest players are recalibrating, with OpenAI recently pivoting its Agentic Commerce Protocol (ACP) and abandoning its ‘instant checkout’.
You’ve probably noticed this yourself. The gap between what AI agents can theoretically do and what your payment stack, your bank, and your customers are actually ready for is wider than the headlines suggest.
Strip away the noise, and the reality of agentic commerce splits into two distinct paths. They operate on very different timelines, and they carry very different levels of risk for your P&L today. Let’s take a look at what those are.
If you spent any time in commerce circles in 2025, you couldn’t move for talk of AI agents. Every conference, every newsletter, every vendor pitch promised the same thing: autonomous AI would soon handle the entire customer journey, end-to-end.
It was compelling, but it was also premature.
Even the industry’s biggest players are recalibrating, with OpenAI recently pivoting its Agentic Commerce Protocol (ACP) and abandoning its ‘instant checkout’.
You’ve probably noticed this yourself. The gap between what AI agents can theoretically do and what your payment stack, your bank, and your customers are actually ready for is wider than the headlines suggest.
Strip away the noise, and the reality of agentic commerce splits into two distinct paths. They operate on very different timelines, and they carry very different levels of risk for your P&L today. Let’s take a look at what those are.


